Playbook · Chapter 1 · Deliverability

Deliverability first, offer second.

If your cold emails are landing in spam, every decision you make afterwards is based on bad data.

The short answer

Cold email deliverability is whether your emails reach the inbox or the spam folder. Fix it before you test copy or offers. Send from separate domains, authenticate them with SPF, DKIM and DMARC, warm mailboxes up over weeks, keep each mailbox to a small daily volume, and verify every list before you send to it.

Almost every failed outbound programme we have inherited was diagnosed wrongly by the team running it. They looked at a 0.4% reply rate and concluded the market did not want the offer. In most cases the market never saw the offer.

This matters more than any copywriting advice you will read. A brilliant email in a spam folder performs worse than a mediocre email in an inbox. So placement comes first, always, and nothing downstream gets optimised until it is healthy.

What is cold email deliverability?

Deliverability is the share of your emails that land in the primary inbox, rather than bouncing, landing in spam, or being quietly filtered into a folder nobody checks. It is different from "delivery". An email can be delivered, meaning the receiving server accepted it, and still never be seen.

Google and Microsoft decide where your email goes based on three things: whether you are who you say you are (authentication), how your sending domain and mailbox have behaved historically (reputation), and how recipients react to what you send (engagement). Cold email is hard on all three, because you are a stranger sending to people who did not ask to hear from you. The setup below exists to keep each of those signals clean.

The non-negotiables

If you want to see exactly how many mailboxes and domains your volume needs, we wrote a separate guide: how many mailboxes you need for cold email.

How to tell if spam is your real problem

Open rates are increasingly unreliable as a signal. Apple Mail opens emails automatically, many corporate filters click links to scan them, and some teams switch tracking off entirely because the tracking pixel itself hurts placement. So use behaviour instead.

Then test directly. Run seed accounts across Google, Microsoft and the common enterprise filters, send to them as part of every campaign, and check inbox versus spam placement. It is unglamorous and it will save you a quarter.

What to do if you are already in spam

  1. Stop sending from the affected mailboxes. Do not try to push through it. More volume from a flagged mailbox makes the reputation worse.
  2. Check authentication. A surprising number of "spam problems" are a broken DKIM record or a missing DMARC policy.
  3. Check bounce and complaint rates. If either spiked, the list is the cause. Re-verify it before anything else.
  4. Rest and re-warm, or replace. A lightly damaged domain can recover with a couple of weeks of warmup-only traffic. A badly damaged one is cheaper to retire. This is exactly why you never send from your main domain.
  5. Look at the copy last. Spammy wording matters far less than people think. Links, images, tracking and volume patterns matter far more.

The rule

Do not test copy, do not test offers, and do not draw conclusions about your market until placement is verified healthy. Testing on top of broken infrastructure produces confident, expensive, wrong decisions.

Common questions

Can I send cold email from Google Workspace or Microsoft 365?

Yes, and most serious programmes do, because mail from those providers starts with a good reputation. The rules above still apply: separate domains, low volume per mailbox, and a proper warmup.

How long does warmup take?

Plan for two to three weeks before a new mailbox sends any cold volume, then ramp up gradually. More detail in how long cold email takes to book meetings.

Does a good reply rate mean my deliverability is fine?

Mostly, yes. A healthy reply rate is the best evidence that you are reaching the inbox. See what a good cold email reply rate is for benchmarks.