Guides · Agency vs in-house

Cold email agency vs in-house SDR: which is right for you?

The true cost of a hire, how long each option takes to work, and who carries the risk.

The short answer

An in-house SDR in the UK typically costs £50,000 to £75,000 a year once salary, commission, employer costs, tools and management are added, and takes around three months to ramp. A cold email agency usually costs £20,000 to £60,000 a year and can book first meetings within weeks. Agencies win on speed and scale. An SDR wins when you need multi-channel, relationship-heavy prospecting and are ready to manage it.

This is one of the most common decisions a growing B2B company faces. Founders are often doing the selling themselves, pipeline is lumpy, and the question is whether to hire someone or hand outbound to a specialist. Both can work. They suit different situations.

The true cost of an in-house SDR

The salary is only the start. Here is a typical UK picture for one SDR:

CostRough annual figure
Base salary£28,000 to £38,000
Commission or bonus£8,000 to £18,000
Employer National Insurance and pension£5,000 to £9,000
Tools: data, sending platform, LinkedIn Sales Navigator, dialler£3,000 to £8,000
Recruitment (agency fee or your time)£0 to £8,000
Management timeHard to price, but real
Totalabout £50,000 to £75,000

Then add the ramp. Most SDRs take around three months to reach full productivity, and SDR tenure is short. Many companies find they are re-hiring within 18 months, which resets the ramp.

The cost of a cold email agency

Agency pricing is covered in detail in how much a cold email agency costs. In short, expect roughly £1,500 to £6,000 a month, or £18,000 to £72,000 a year, usually with infrastructure, data and copywriting included. At bookd it is £1,800 a month, and nothing beyond the first payment is due until 10 meetings are booked.

Side by side

In-house SDRCold email agency
Annual cost£50k to £75k£18k to £72k
Time to first meetings2 to 4 months including hiring3 to 6 weeks
VolumeLimited by one person's hoursCan cover a whole market
ChannelsEmail, phone, LinkedInMostly email
ExpertiseDepends on the hireBuilt across many clients
Knowledge of your productDeep over timeGood, but not as deep
Risk if it failsNotice periods, re-hiringUsually a monthly or short term
Management neededHighLow

When an agency makes more sense

When an in-house SDR makes more sense

The option most people miss: both

The two are not mutually exclusive. A common pattern that works well: the agency runs cold email at scale and books the first conversations, while an in-house rep takes the meetings, follows up and closes. The agency handles volume and testing. Your team handles relationships. You also get a proven playbook if you later decide to bring outbound fully in-house.

Questions to ask yourself before deciding

  1. How many qualified meetings a month do we actually need to hit our revenue target?
  2. How big is our total market, and how much of it are we reaching today?
  3. Who would manage an SDR, and do they have the time?
  4. What happens to pipeline if the hire does not work out in six months?
  5. What is a qualified meeting worth to us? The ROI calculator helps here.

Common questions

Can an agency really know my product as well as an employee?

Not as deeply, and it does not need to. The agency's job is to start the right conversations. Your team's job is to have them. A good agency will spend time learning your offer and your best customers before writing a word.

Is outsourcing outbound risky for my brand?

It can be if the agency sends from your main domain or sends careless emails. Insist on separate sending domains, approve the copy, and ask how opt-outs are handled. See how to choose a cold email agency.

Prove the channel before you hire.

We will build and run it. You only pay again once 10 meetings are in your calendar.