The short answer
Choose a cold email agency on evidence, not promises. Ask for case studies with real numbers in your type of market, find out exactly what is included, who owns the domains and data, how they protect deliverability, how fast replies reach you, and what happens if they miss target. Walk away from anyone who guarantees huge numbers, sends from your main domain, or locks you into a long contract before proving anything.
Yes, we are a cold email agency, so read this with that in mind. We have tried to write the guide we would want if we were buying, including the questions that would catch a bad agency, us included.
12 questions to ask before you sign
Results and fit
- Can you show results in a market like mine? Ask for specific numbers: emails sent, reply rate, meetings booked, and over what period. "We generated millions in pipeline" is not a number.
- How big is my market, and how much of it will you reach each month? A good agency will size your total addressable market before quoting. See why coverage matters.
- What counts as a qualified meeting? Get the definition in writing, especially on pay-per-meeting deals.
- When would you tell me cold email is not right for us? An agency that has never turned anyone away is not being honest about fit.
How they work
- How do you protect deliverability? You want to hear: separate domains, SPF, DKIM and DMARC, warmup, low volume per mailbox, list verification. See the deliverability chapter.
- How many angles do you test, and how? One email with four follow-ups is not testing. See how to test cold email copy.
- Where does the data come from, and is it verified? Bounces destroy domains. Ask what their bounce rate target is.
- Who reads the replies, and how fast do interested prospects reach me? Same day should be the standard.
Commercials and ownership
- What exactly is included in the price? Infrastructure, data, software, copywriting, reply handling. See what a cold email agency costs.
- Who owns the domains, the data and the campaign results if we part ways?
- What is the minimum term, and what happens if you miss target?
- Can I see the numbers whenever I want? Live dashboards beat monthly PDFs.
Red flags
- Guaranteeing huge numbers before seeing your market. Nobody knows your reply rate before testing.
- Sending from your main domain. If it gets flagged, your normal business email suffers too.
- No questions about your offer, deal size or best customers. They are selling a template, not a programme.
- Judging success by open rates. Open rates are unreliable now. Meetings are what count.
- Long lock-ins with nothing proven. Six months upfront before a single meeting puts all the risk on you.
- Vague reporting. If you cannot see sends, replies and meetings, you cannot judge the work.
- One generic sequence for everyone. Ask to see the segments and angles they plan to test.
Green flags
- They ask hard questions about your deal value and market size before quoting.
- They tell you what could go wrong, not just what could go right.
- They share some of the risk through guarantees, performance pricing or short terms.
- They publish what they know. A detailed public playbook is a good sign they are not hiding a thin process.
- Their own outreach to you is good. If an agency's cold email to you was sloppy, expect the same for your prospects.
How to compare two proposals
| Compare | Why it matters |
| Contacts reached per month | The biggest driver of meetings at scale |
| Angles tested per month | How fast they will find what works |
| What is included | Hidden extras can double the real price |
| Meeting definition | Stops you paying for unqualified calls |
| Risk sharing | Who pays if it does not work |
| Time to first meetings | Pre-warmed infrastructure saves weeks |
Where bookd fits
We are a done-for-you cold email agency for B2B companies, and we suit businesses with a deal value of at least a few thousand pounds and a market of over about 10,000 contacts. We cover the full market, include all infrastructure and data, and price so that we carry the early risk: £1,800 to start, nothing more until 10 meetings are booked, then 5 a month guaranteed or no invoice. If we do not think cold email will work for you, we will say so on the first call.